Review: ASOS vs TFNC pleated midi skirt

Left: ASOS | Right: TFNC

I was on the hunt for a nude-pink coloured pleated midi skirt for several months. I couldn’t find anything from my usual fashion retailers or pre-owned on eBay. Midway through November, there were a lot of click frenzy online promotions going on, and I used ASOS’s 30% off sitewide sale to pick up the ASOS Pleated Midi Skirt (Nude) and TFNC Pleated Midi Skirt (Light mauve) in my usual size 6 as they looked like exactly what I was after. I order from ASOS once in a blue moon and now with free-returns from Australia, I am slightly more keen to try things then return them (previously I would have to pay return shipping).

Unfortunately the TFNC size 6 was too small and I was unable to zip up and actually breathe. ASOS don’t do exchanges so I couldn’t get the same 30% discount for reordering in a different size (I even emailed to see if they could honour the previous discount code for this situation, but they couldn’t). However Black Friday came around so I just ordered a size 8 with their 20% off discount. (I note, as always, that Black Friday sales are not actually that spectacular online. I always find better sales throughout the year.) It wasn’t too big a deal. ASOS free returns are also really easy now!

Both skirts are 100% polyester and fully lined. The tag says hand wash only but I think that’s extremely silly and will definitely be throwing it in the machine. The TFNC lining is a thicker material and very elasticated (almost like a jersey material), which might make it more comfortable if I were to start sprinting, haha. Both have a waist band, side zip and hook and eye closure. The zip on the TFNC skirt is much stiffer and gives me a lot of trouble (both skirts that came had this same problem so it’s not an isolated problem). Both are also priced at $59 and available in a few different colours. They are not high quality but well priced to fill a wardrobe hole.

The ASOS skirt is noticeably longer by several centimetres. It’s kind of an awkwardly too-long-midi/almost-maxi length. For reference, I’m 165cm but have short legs for my proportions (damn) so even the TFNC one is probably a tad long on me and I may end up altering it (just look at it on the model!). I would have been happy to keep both though, as I really liked the two colours – the ASOS one is a peachy pale nude, while the TFNC one is a dusty grey-toned pink. They also have different weights and pleating – the TFNC one is heavier and has skinnier pleats. However I noticed that the lining of the ASOS skirt was bunched at the waist band and these folds showed through quite obviously since the outer layer was thin. I’m not sure if it was an isolated stitching problem, but it annoyed me a lot. Ultimately this made the decision for me and I decided to return the ASOS one (and the TFNC in the size that didn’t fit).

ASOS Pleated Midi Skirt (Nude) | TFNC Pleated Midi Skirt (Light mauve) (+ cashback via Cash Rewards)